Ask a police officer which businesses see armed robberies most often, and gas stations will come up quickly. The reasons are not mysterious. What is less widely understood is how that well-known risk shapes the legal obligations of the people who own and run these stations.
In short, a business that knows it is a target cannot simply hope for the best. It must respond with sensible precautions for everyone who comes onto its lot.
What makes a fuel stop a target
Several features combine to make gas stations and convenience stores appealing to robbers:
Long hours. Many never close. Others stay open well past the time most shops have locked up, which means a lone clerk may be working at 2 a.m. with few people around.
Cash on hand. Even with card readers at every pump, stores still take cash for snacks, lottery tickets, cigarettes, and fuel paid inside.
Quick, distracted customers. People are focused on the pump, the price, or their phone. A car door left open with a purse on the seat is an easy grab.
Easy getaways. Stations sit on busy roads and highway exits, giving an offender a fast way out.
Taken together, these traits explain why convenience stores and fuel stations appear again and again in robbery and shooting statistics.
Knowledge creates obligation
Most premises-liability rules start from a simple idea: a business has to use reasonable care against hazards it is aware of, or ought to be aware of, that threaten its visitors. For gas station owners, the danger is usually documented in their own files. Holdup reports, calls to 911, footage of fights in the lot, complaints from employees: all of it tells the owner what kind of risk the station faces.
Once that knowledge exists, the owner has a duty to respond in proportion to the threat. When management shrugs off a known crime problem and someone is hurt, the station can be held liable.
What a reasonable response can look like
The precise measures depend on the location and its history. A rural stop with no prior incidents may need little beyond good lighting and working locks. A city station that has been robbed several times in a year is a different story. Depending on the risk, reasonable security might involve:
- Bright, maintained lighting over the pumps, the store entrance, and the parking area
- A camera system that actually records and is checked by someone
- Functioning alarms and panic buttons tied to monitoring or police
- Door locks and night-window setups that let clerks serve customers without exposure
- A guard during high-risk hours when there is a documented robbery pattern
- Clear policies for handling loiterers and drug activity on the lot
Not just customers
Clerks and cashiers face these dangers every shift. Their rights may depend on workers' compensation rules in their state, which can limit lawsuits against a direct employer. However, claims against other companies involved in the property, such as a separate owner or a security contractor, may still be possible. Delivery drivers, contractors, and people simply walking through the lot can also be harmed when security fails.
Store design can help or hurt
The physical layout of a station also matters. Windows plastered with posters and promotional signs block the clerk's view of the pumps and keep passing drivers from seeing a robbery in progress. A register placed out of sight from the entrance gives an offender privacy. Overgrown landscaping or a dumpster area at the edge of the lot can give someone a place to wait unseen.
Safety professionals often recommend clear sightlines, a visible register, limited cash in the drawer, and signage telling the public that cameras are recording. When a station with a robbery history keeps a layout that invites crime, jurors may well hear about that choice.
Ignoring the warnings
Courts look closely at what an owner did after earlier crimes. Replacing a broken light within a day tells one story. Leaving it dark for months while robberies continue tells another. Removing a guard to save money right after a shooting, or letting cameras go unrepaired despite repeated holdups, can make a station's position very difficult once a customer is seriously hurt.
What injured people can pursue
Victims may seek compensation for medical treatment, missed income, and the psychological harm that often follows an armed robbery or shooting. Families who lose someone may file a wrongful-death claim.
Getting advice
Close to 500 inadequate-security claims have come through The Haggard Law Firm, and one of them ended in a $102.7 million verdict, the biggest any American jury has returned in this type of case. That figure is gross; fees and expenses come out of it. The result reflects that case alone.
Representation is contingent: no recovery means no attorney's fee. Speak with someone confidentially, at no charge, by calling (305) 446-5700.
Attorney advertising. General information only, offered for educational purposes; it does not constitute legal advice. Calling or writing to the firm does not by that act establish representation. Prior verdicts do not assure future success, since every matter depends on its particular circumstances.