Shot or Stabbed on Someone Else's Property in Texas? How a Negligent-Security Claim Can Hold a Careless Owner Responsible When the Attacker Cannot

A gunshot in a Houston apartment breezeway. A knife pulled in a San Antonio nightclub parking lot. A robbery turned violent at an all-night store off a Dallas interstate. Each of these scenes leaves behind a person whose recovery may stretch for months or years, along with bills that arrive long before any criminal case wraps up.

Blame naturally lands first on whoever fired or stabbed. Often, though, that individual has no money, no insurance, or no known identity. Texas law offers a second avenue: a civil lawsuit against the business or landlord whose lax protection gave the attacker an opening.

The core idea behind the claim

Texas courts expect owners and operators to take ordinary care so that shoppers, renters, hotel guests, and other invitees are not left exposed to crime the owner knew of, or should have known of, when that risk was both foreseeable and unreasonable. A negligent-security suit is built around that obligation.

The victim is not asking the owner to answer for the crime as though the owner committed it. Rather, the lawsuit zeroes in on things such as dead lighting, broken gates, absent guards, or ignored warnings, and argues that those lapses made a predictable assault possible. The case runs independently of any prosecution, so it may proceed even if no one is ever arrested.

Proving the danger was predictable

Texas has a specific checklist for foreseeability that comes from the state supreme court's 1998 decision in Timberwalk Apartments, Partners, Inc. v. Cain. Judges review the earlier crimes reported on or around the premises and pose five questions about them:

  • How near were they to the place of the attack?
  • How recently did they occur?
  • How often did they happen?
  • How similar were they to the attack at issue?
  • How widely were they publicized or otherwise known?

A pattern of armed robberies in the same lot last year tells a far different story than a single shoplifting incident a decade ago.

Showing the risk was unreasonable

Foreseeability alone does not end the inquiry. In UDR Texas Properties, L.P. v. Petrie, decided in 2017, the Supreme Court of Texas made clear that a victim must also demonstrate that the risk was unreasonable, which means weighing the danger against the cost and practicality of preventing it. Evidence about what better lighting, functioning access control, or a patrol would have required can be just as important as the crime history.

Common Texas settings

Claims in Harris, Dallas, Bexar, Travis, Tarrant, and El Paso counties regularly involve:

  • Apartment complexes and other multifamily housing
  • Bars, nightclubs, and live-music venues
  • Convenience stores and gas stations
  • Hotels and motels near highways
  • Parking garages and shopping-center lots

First steps after a Texas attack

Medical care comes first. After that, request the incident number from the police agency that responded, whether that was a city department or a county sheriff. Jot down where on the property the attack happened, what time it was, and what you saw of lights, locks, cameras, and staff. Hold onto texts, receipts, and photos placing you there, and let a lawyer field calls from the property's insurer.

Deadlines to keep in mind

The Texas filing window for most injury suits is two years, counted from the incident. Relatives bringing a death claim typically have two years from the day their loved one passed. Surveillance recordings and visitor logs can disappear in a matter of days, so waiting even a few weeks can cost valuable proof.

How shared fault works

Texas follows a proportionate-responsibility system with a bar at 51 percent. A victim found partly at fault can still recover, minus that percentage, as long as the victim's share does not exceed 50 percent. Above that line, the claim fails entirely.

What a claim can recover

Compensatory damages in an ordinary Texas negligence case have no statutory ceiling. That generally covers hospital care, therapy, lost paychecks, reduced earning ability, and pain and anguish. In fatal cases, relatives may seek funeral expenses as well as lost financial support and companionship.

A national practice that coordinates with Texas lawyers

The Haggard Law Firm, located in Coral Gables, Florida, has taken roughly 500 security-negligence matters in many states, and a jury in one of them returned $102.7 million, a verdict the firm calls the largest ever for negligent security; that amount is gross. Michael A. Haggard's license is from Florida; the State Bar of Texas has not admitted him. On Texas matters, he works as co-counsel alongside a Texas-licensed attorney and, when the presiding court allows, files a pro hac vice motion covering just that lawsuit. A lawyer admitted in Texas participates in every Texas matter the firm handles.

There are no attorney fees unless the client recovers. Texans hurt by violent crime, and grieving families, may phone (305) 446-5700 and speak privately without charge.

Attorney advertising. This overview of Texas law is general in nature and does not amount to legal advice for your circumstances; no attorney-client bond forms until both sides sign an engagement agreement. Michael A. Haggard is admitted in Florida only. A result in one lawsuit cannot predict the outcome of a different one.

Benjamín Bélanger
Benjamín Bélanger

Avid coffee fanatic. General creator. Passionate twitter fanatic. Certified coffee evangelist. Subtly charming music enthusiast. Unapologetic music buff.

Leave a Comment

All fileds with * are required