Jardel, Koutoufaris and the Totality of Prior Incidents: How Delaware Courts Decide Whether a Wilmington Shooting or Stabbing Was Foreseeable

In nearly every negligent-security case, the property owner's main defense is the same: nobody could have seen this coming. Whether that argument works depends heavily on the state. Some jurisdictions demand evidence of nearly identical crimes at the same spot before they will find an attack foreseeable. Delaware takes a broader and more practical view, and that approach can make a real difference for people hurt at Wilmington properties.

The foundation: Jardel Co. v. Hughes

Delaware's modern rule traces to Jardel Co. v. Hughes, a Delaware Supreme Court decision involving a shopping center. In that case, the court adopted the approach of Section 344 of the Restatement (Second) of Torts. Under that principle, a business that opens its property to the public for its own commercial purposes must exercise reasonable care to protect visitors from harmful acts of third parties, including criminals, when the business has reason to anticipate such conduct.

In plain terms, a store, mall, bar, hotel, apartment complex, or similar operation cannot ignore what is happening on its own premises. If experience tells the owner that crime is likely, the owner must take sensible precautions.

Rejecting the "same crime" requirement

The most important feature of Delaware law for crime victims is what it does not require. Delaware does not insist that the victim prove an earlier crime exactly like theirs happened at the same location. Instead, courts consider the overall history of incidents on or near the property.

That history can include lesser offenses. Thefts, fights, vandalism, drug activity, trespassing, and other disturbances may together show that a violent attack was a foreseeable risk, even if no one had been shot or stabbed there before. The question is whether the accumulated warning signs would have led a sensible operator to expect that someone could get hurt.

Reaffirmed in Koutoufaris v. Dick

The Delaware Supreme Court later reinforced this approach in Koutoufaris v. Dick, a subsequent premises-security case involving a business's customers. The decision confirmed that a business's knowledge of prior incidents, even those not identical to the attack at issue, can support a finding that the owner should have anticipated danger and acted to reduce it.

Together, these decisions give Wilmington plaintiffs a framework that focuses on whether the property's overall track record made violence predictable.

How far the inquiry reaches

Because Delaware looks at incidents both on and near the premises, the neighborhood around a property may be relevant. A parking garage next to a block with repeated robberies, a convenience store on a corridor with frequent assaults, or an apartment building surrounded by drug activity may all carry elevated risk the owner should have recognized. The spotlight stays on this owner's awareness, real or imputed, yet the surrounding blocks can help fill in that picture.

Evidence that builds foreseeability in Wilmington

Lawyers investigating a Wilmington case typically gather:

  • Wilmington Police Department dispatch history and reports linked to the address
  • Internal incident logs, security reports, and manager emails
  • Complaints from tenants, customers, or employees
  • Records connected to the city's Public Nuisance Properties program, which tracks locations based on nuisance calls and criminal activity
  • Crime data for the surrounding blocks
  • Prior lawsuits, insurance claims, or code enforcement actions involving the property

Foreseeability is only part of the case

Showing that crime was foreseeable establishes that the owner had a duty to act. The case must also show that the owner's response fell short of reasonable care, such as broken locks, poor lighting, absent or untrained guards, or uncontrolled access, and that the failure contributed to the attack. Delaware's comparative negligence rules and other defenses may also come into play.

Recovering for the harm

Once those pieces are in place, an injured person can pursue treatment costs, lost income, and pain and suffering, with no statutory ceiling on compensatory damages in an ordinary Delaware negligence case. Where the attack was fatal, relatives can pursue a wrongful-death action.

About the firm's Delaware practice

Michael A. Haggard, of The Haggard Law Firm in Coral Gables, practices under a Florida license and has no license to practice in Delaware. Because premises-security litigation is what the firm does, he joins Delaware cases as co-counsel with an attorney licensed in Delaware and requests permission to appear pro hac vice in the specific case where court rules allow.

The firm's experience spans roughly 500 negligent-security matters, and one of those cases produced a $102.7 million verdict, the most ever awarded by an American jury in a security-negligence case (a gross sum).

There is no legal fee unless the case recovers money. Speak with the firm confidentially and at no cost by calling (305) 446-5700.

Attorney advertising. Case descriptions here are simplified summaries of Delaware law, not legal advice, and should be confirmed with counsel. Reaching out is not, in itself, an agreement for representation. Mr. Haggard is licensed in Florida. Earlier outcomes do not predict later ones.

Benjamín Bélanger
Benjamín Bélanger

Avid coffee fanatic. General creator. Passionate twitter fanatic. Certified coffee evangelist. Subtly charming music enthusiast. Unapologetic music buff.

Leave a Comment

All fileds with * are required